ROHANI ROSHNI,An understanding.

Discussion on doctrinal issues
Locked
tret
Posts: 1196
Joined: Thu Sep 09, 2010 2:09 pm

Post by tret »

Shiraz.Virani wrote: Tret very nicely put. But do you think god is limited or found only in imams[as] ??
I would put it differently. I think -- and it's my pure understanding, I may be wrong -- we see God's proof on earth. It's not necessarily God Himself that appears in things/people. It's rather the manifestation of God's Proof. There's a slight difference.

Shiraz.Virani wrote: How do god communicate with various species ???
There's a book called "Mantiq-ul Tayr" [Conference of Birds] that I find very useful by "Attar". You may want to take a look.


Shiraz.Virani wrote: Do you think only Ismailis reach jannat and other go to other places ???
I really don't think so. I don't think "Jannat" is only reserved to ismailies. However, I do think ismailie is the shortest path to reach their. And we really should try to figure out who we are and where we belong while we are well and very much alive, because once we die, we will never be able to. :)

Maulana-i-Rumi was not an ismailie but was in love with Shams-i-Tabriz (Maulana shams-ul-din Mohammad), and He[Rumi] definitly reached to his place. Like him there are many others who have reach to their place who were not necessarily ismailies. On the same token, there are ismailies who are just by name, and they don't demonistrate anything like a true ismailie. So, it's like jungle and you can find any kind of people.
agakhani
Posts: 2059
Joined: Wed May 07, 2008 8:49 am
Location: TEXAS. U.S.A.

Post by agakhani »

Hz Ali was human being and it is Kufr to consider him as subprime deity.
It may be for some non-Ismailis peoples but we Ismailis believes that H. Ali had divine power, same divine power Prophet had too. The divine powers comes in our current H.I.

PIR = PROPHET
SHAH= H.ALI so Consider and believe that H. Ali had divine power doesn't consider Ismailis are "Kufr" because it is our fundamental belief for 14 centuries old tradition!!.
agakhani
Posts: 2059
Joined: Wed May 07, 2008 8:49 am
Location: TEXAS. U.S.A.

Post by agakhani »

There's a book called "Mantiq-ul Tayr" [Conference of Birds] that I find very useful by "Attar". You may want to take a look.
Sorry to interrupt you both :-

I read above Mantiq-ul-Tayr ( The language of Birds) books of Farīd al-Dīn Muḥammad ibn Ibrāhīm ʿAṭṭār but I didn't find any direct communication with god (i.e. birds and God dialect) It is possible that I read that book long time ago so that time I was not mature enough to understand the essence of the bookIt is a great book in Persian language and it is written on Birds journey to search "Simorgh" Be honest with you this great book has lots of Ruhani meaning and tells about 'SUFISM' but not the communication with God.
tret
Posts: 1196
Joined: Thu Sep 09, 2010 2:09 pm

Post by tret »

agakhani wrote:
There's a book called "Mantiq-ul Tayr" [Conference of Birds] that I find very useful by "Attar". You may want to take a look.
Sorry to interrupt you both :-

I read above Mantiq-ul-Tayr ( The language of Birds) books of Farīd al-Dīn Muḥammad ibn Ibrāhīm ʿAṭṭār but I didn't find any direct communication with god (i.e. birds and God dialect) It is possible that I read that book long time ago so that time I was not mature enough to understand the essence of the bookIt is a great book in Persian language and it is written on Birds journey to search "Simorgh" Be honest with you this great book has lots of Ruhani meaning and tells about 'SUFISM' but not the communication with God.
Not a problem at all, agakhani brother. It's not interruption at all.

You are very correct about the author and the book. And you are also correct about the communication with God [or no communication].

But, what I believe is that when one finds the divine and understands then there's no need for communication as he/she becomes one with the divine. Communication is something that we human try to articulate as we only understands what we are capable of. When one realizes and become one with divine, then there's no communication as he becomes HIM and it is all one.

So, if we try to understand that, then question on 'communication' with God or 'seeing God' becomes irrelevant.
ShamsB
Posts: 1118
Joined: Wed Aug 04, 2004 5:20 pm

Post by ShamsB »

zznoor wrote:
ALI KE PUPPET AAP BHI BAN JAAVO
Hz Ali was human being and it is Kufr to consider him as subprime deity.
It is interesting to note that Admin keeps letting you post garbage on each and every post - and how this post from being about ruhani roshni has diverted into you defecating all over again - but i guess it is time to take your shoe once again and beat you on the head with it..and plus i am a bit bored - so this will be entertaining for me as well.

So here goes.

1. you're right Hazrat Ali was not a subprime deity - but he was the SOLE diety - the PRIME diety - and yes..to ME and others - Hazrat ALI - was and is GOD - and that light - NOOR is present in the Present Day Imam and will continue to be manifest till the day of judgement.
The Qur'an refers to this phenomenon - as Imam-e-Mubeen - THE MANIFEST IMAM.
and by the way - when I speak of ALI - I don't refer to the BODY - but rather the LIGHT - the NOOR - but i guess in your shariati mindset - the soul doesn't exist and nor does it matter - your mind goes back to the 7th Century Hazrat Ali - who was assassinated by Ibn Muljim....

Using a Sunni source - that even you can't deny - neither can your Wahhabist Handlers -
The "Sira" of the Prophet - the Biography - on which the majority of the Sunni Belief system is based (though written 200 years after the death of the Prophet) - upon Miraj the Prophet speaks of meeting Harun in Paradise - along with the other Prophets....
now to tie this together - there is a hadith of the prophet - which is authenticated by all the different scholars (Bukhari, Tabari, Al Islam, even Anas ibn Malik in Al- Mawta; you forgot I have a phd didn't you?)
the prophet has remarked on more than ONE occasion - "ALI YOU ARE TO ME AS HARUN WAS TO MUSA"
so what does that make ALI....
have any hair left after that beating?

Speaking of Pirs - you insult the prophet by degrading and insulting the position - as a former ismaili - you must be aware that Prophet Mohammed is considered our FIRST PIR...but somehow you permit yourself to insult that office.

In terms of the knowledge of the Pirs - what do you know about their levels?
Explain to me - how it was that Pir Satgur Noor (Nooruddin Mohammed) was able to talk about distance between stars using the word Tejh Waras - literally translated means - LIGHT YEARS - about 1000 years?

Or that Pir Hassan Kabirdeen spoke of the world being Egg shaped - and circumnavigating the sun - way before Copernicus and Galileo?

and FYI - all of our Pirs are from Ahl-e-Bayt; which you forget or aren't aware of.

Speaking of the Imams - if the Sunni faith is so strong - how is it that all the 4 major schools of Sunni Jurisprudence (Shafi, Hanbali, Maliki etc) trace their origins from a Shi'a Imam - Jafar-as-Sadiq?...hm..weren't the Sunni sources enough that they had to learn from a Shia Imam??

It is the same Shia Imam that has said - that if there were 2 people left on the planet earth - one would be the IMAM - think of the importance of that statement in perpetuity - The IMAM has always been here....without the IMAM even for a split second - the world would cease to exist!!

Anyways - authorship of the Imams - Hazrat Ali's works - Nahjul Balagha
Imam Zainul Abideen was an avid writer, as was Imam Jafar As Sadiq - whose works are plentiful and can be read, many Imams wrote- just because you are illiterate doesn't mean that knowledge is not out there.

You act like just because you haven't seen electricity anyone else talking about it must be crazy.

Seriously - crawl back into the kanzu (africans will get this..i don't know what it's called in urdu - the frock that muslim men wear) of the wahabist maulvi who's feeding you half baked garbage - and leave us alone.

As you have stated - we're kufr - let us sin and we'll deal with it on the day of judgement..why do you worry?

We're happy drowning - go save someone who actually wants to be saved.

ALI is ALLAH to me and that is the ultimate and only truth.

Shams
nuseri
Posts: 1375
Joined: Thu Jul 12, 2012 8:54 am

Post by nuseri »

Ya Ali Madad:

I have in my city a Shariati associate in one of my works.

He always refers to Hadiths(85% fakes one) explained to him xx number of speakers who fotos are also there on the net.

Few weeks back I told him to gather fotos of all of those Shariati speaking against the word of GOD according to me.
I also told him to collects fotos of persons all non muslims serving in the cause of God and humanity. and gave him few names like Dalai lama,Mother Teresa,Padre Pio and fer others.

In fortune telling there are also many who can tell the fortune and fate of the person by face reading.
I told him to take 6 of Shariati Quran speakers and other Non muslims
saintly n pious known persons to a neutral well known Hindu face reader with good accuracy.
He has collected the fotos but feeling shy to take them to the face reader.
I presume he studied the result himself and now avoids me on that topic and also stopped telling me fake Hadiths
This can be done by any reader by Googling images.

Let me tell you 80% of speakers who misunderstood Quran n are speaking against the words of Allah.
have very darkened eye rings,no glow of light in their faces,mostly looking angry or fearful and in tense n restless expressions.No smile on their faces.

Forget the face reader ,any Layman if told which out of those 12 foto
would be heaven or Hell the very next micro second upon their death.
that person verdict can be very clear n visible n take few minutes only.

TRY IT YOURSELF
DUDH KA DUDH AUR PAANI KA PAANI DEKHANGA.

there is an invisible stamp of KUFR on each n every Shariati face.Take it or leave it.People of other religion are much much much better off than them.
Now I have asked him to collect information how were the final last 5-7 years of their life and how did they die of all 12 of them?

He is refusing to do that,maybe the barking group well wisher does a total thesis on above.

SEEING REALITY IS BELIEVING AND NOT WORDS OF PERSON LONG DEAD.
nuseri
Posts: 1375
Joined: Thu Jul 12, 2012 8:54 am

Post by nuseri »

Ya Ali Madad:
Please anyone can find and re post a Hadith of narration of Aisha mentioning Salman Farsi.

I surely read in this forum in one of the posts.I am not good at Googling.

In Christanity it is GOD ( holy father) Holy son ( Jesus) and holy spirit jibreel)called as Holy Trinity.
6th phase n Haqiqat

In Islam being Marifrat n seventh phase( no sound or words of unseen Allah but ALI+lah=Allah himslef on earth). One need to co relate all ENTITY in physical form if ONLY one has the Haqiqati conviction. Otherwise the cube looks like a square to A non Haqiqati.

Jesus= Mohommed.

God(holy/spirtual father)=ALI

Holy spirit = jibraeel= Salman Farsi.

AGAR SETH IDHAAR HAI TO
USKE AAMCHE OR CHAAMCHE BE IDHAR HONA CHAIYE.
a_27826
Posts: 321
Joined: Sun Jan 03, 2010 1:43 pm
Location: Da es salaam
Contact:

Post by a_27826 »

nuseri wrote: In Christanity it is GOD ( holy father) Holy son ( Jesus) and holy spirit jibreel)called as Holy Trinity.
6th phase n Haqiqat

In Islam being Marifrat n seventh phase( no sound or words of unseen Allah but ALI+lah=Allah himslef on earth). One need to co relate all ENTITY in physical form if ONLY one has the Haqiqati conviction. Otherwise the cube looks like a square to A non Haqiqati.

Jesus= Mohommed.

God(holy/spirtual father)=ALI

Holy spirit = jibraeel= Salman Farsi.
Thats what Alawis (a small subsect of Twelvers) believe.

Maybe i am wrong but I dont think we Ismailis hold such belief.

How did you get that belief ?



The 'Alawis believe in the absolute unity and transcendence of God who is undefinable and unknowable. God however reveals himself periodically to man in a Trinitarian form. This has happened seven times in history, the last and final revelation being in 'Ali, Muhammad, and Salman al-Farisi. (Salman was a Persian disciple and close companion of Muhammad).

angelfire.com/az/rescon/mgcalawi.html
tret
Posts: 1196
Joined: Thu Sep 09, 2010 2:09 pm

Post by tret »

I don't think paining everyone with the same brush is wise of us.

And I don't think we should beat zznoor up just because she doesn't agree with us. After all 'shak' [doubt] is a stage of reaching to haqiqat and realization. If we can make her [zznoor] realize the truth, then I guess we have done something good. So, I think we should let her participate in the discussion and who knows, maybe one day she opens up her mind and start listening. I am very certain that she is intelligent and smart.

nuseri - I don't know why you need to compare our belief system with christology to make a point. Let christians praise christ and the concept of trinity. Don't get me wrong, I do respect Jesus. [He is after all our own Hz Issa AS].
ShamsB
Posts: 1118
Joined: Wed Aug 04, 2004 5:20 pm

Post by ShamsB »

tret wrote:I don't think paining everyone with the same brush is wise of us.

And I don't think we should beat zznoor up just because she doesn't agree with us. After all 'shak' [doubt] is a stage of reaching to haqiqat and realization. If we can make her [zznoor] realize the truth, then I guess we have done something good. So, I think we should let her participate in the discussion and who knows, maybe one day she opens up her mind and start listening. I am very certain that she is intelligent and smart.

nuseri - I don't know why you need to compare our belief system with christology to make a point. Let christians praise christ and the concept of trinity. Don't get me wrong, I do respect Jesus. [He is after all our own Hz Issa AS].
Tret,

I am okay with zznoor stating that she wasn't happy with our faith and left it - or that she doesn't believe that our way or rather my way is the right way - but that doesn't give her the right nor the stance to judge me - last time i checked - she wasn't Allah.

Judge not lest you be judged (Jesus I think).

I am okay with her believing whatever she believes - what i object to is her putting garbage and copy pasting wahabist material in the middle of discussions.

For me - an individual's relationship to the almighty is between Ali/Allah and the individual - for me - there is no need or requirement for any intellectual proof or argument or debate. I believe what I believe and I find satisfaction and happiness with it - and I am happy for others to believe whatever they want to; however as you said - don't paint us with a paintbrush - just because zznoor is seeking validation for her decisions - she's hellbent on attacking us.

and every time she's come up with her crackpot theories and garbage - we've debunked her so called truths with proofs from sunni sources...she began by calling herself sunni - then moved to Shia Ithna Asheri and now she's moved back to twelver - she changes her faith based upon what argument she can copy and paste...

there is no intellectual search there - because she cannot articulate her position nor is she even reading what people are writing - she's copying/pasting ...
from here to the wahabist site - or the twelver site and whatever responses they give her - she copies and pastes here...

I am surprised that Admin hasn't taken action.

Shams
nuseri
Posts: 1375
Joined: Thu Jul 12, 2012 8:54 am

Post by nuseri »

To a_27826: Ya Ali Madad.

I really appreciate your constructive and objective research.It is neutral and unbiased.
As you asked the question.It is my conviction and more than belief of Salman Farsi.May be I must have been an Alawi in one my past life cycles. :wink:

Please could you post other Ayats stating physical features of Ali+lah+Allah with eyes,walking,sitting on throne,speaking,etc etc.

Ignore the Shariati,She has lost her barking but has a lot of recorded barking of other dogs in the van.It is for the Admin on
how much parking space to be given to the van.

Has anybody located the Hadith of Aisha on Salman Farsi ?
agakhani
Posts: 2059
Joined: Wed May 07, 2008 8:49 am
Location: TEXAS. U.S.A.

Post by agakhani »

If we can make her [zznoor] realize the truth, then I guess we have done something good.
Brother Treat,

Good thinking above and we all should try that way but I have one question for you Tret, Do you think she will change? if she had ever realized the truth of Ismailism then she would not have left this true and correct path 'ISMAILISM'. period so I do not have much hope but who knows I have seen many Ismailis came back after they left Ismailism and realized that they make mistake and came back so, we all should keep our finger crossed hopping that happen to sister ZZNoor.
zznoor
Posts: 1017
Joined: Sun Dec 06, 2009 1:38 pm

Post by zznoor »

there is no intellectual search there - because she cannot articulate her position nor is she even reading what people are writing - she's copying/pasting ...
from here to the wahabist site - or the twelver site and whatever responses they give her - she copies and pastes here...
With 1400 years of scholarly material available from Shia, Sunni and orient list sauces why do I have to formulate something and call it intellectual search.

Stop attacking Quran until omitted, additional and/ or altered Ayas are posted.
zznoor
Posts: 1017
Joined: Sun Dec 06, 2009 1:38 pm

Post by zznoor »

agakhani wrote:
If we can make her [zznoor] realize the truth, then I guess we have done something good.
Brother Treat,

Good thinking above and we all should try that way but I have one question for you Tret, Do you think she will change? if she had ever realized the truth of Ismailism then she would not have left this true and correct path 'ISMAILISM'. period so I do not have much hope but who knows I have seen many Ismailis came back after they left Ismailism and realized that they make mistake and came back so, we all should keep our finger crossed hopping that happen to sister ZZNoor.
Truth is in Quran and authentic Sunna, not in Biddati material or firkas.
zznoor
Posts: 1017
Joined: Sun Dec 06, 2009 1:38 pm

Post by zznoor »

Please could you post other Ayats stating physical features of Ali+lah+Allah with eyes,walking,sitting on throne,speaking,etc etc.
All human words used for Allah are used in their basic sense and meaning, and not with reference to their physical connotation. For instance, when, the word "sight" is used with respect to Allah, it does not mean that Allah has an eye like men and animals with which He sees. Similarly when we say that Allah 'hears' or 'grips' or 'grasps', it does not mean that He hears through ears, or grips or grasps with the hand like us. These words are used in a metaphorical sense and only a man of very poor intelligence would have the misconception that hearing or seeing or grasping is not possible except in the limited and specific sense in which we experience it.
tret
Posts: 1196
Joined: Thu Sep 09, 2010 2:09 pm

Post by tret »

zznoor wrote:
agakhani wrote:
If we can make her [zznoor] realize the truth, then I guess we have done something good.
Brother Treat,

Good thinking above and we all should try that way but I have one question for you Tret, Do you think she will change? if she had ever realized the truth of Ismailism then she would not have left this true and correct path 'ISMAILISM'. period so I do not have much hope but who knows I have seen many Ismailis came back after they left Ismailism and realized that they make mistake and came back so, we all should keep our finger crossed hopping that happen to sister ZZNoor.
Truth is in Quran and authentic Sunna, not in Biddati material or firkas.
True! But the true path is through which the correct interpretation of Islam is done. Qur'an is full mysteries and hidden secrets and a Guide is a MUST for the correct and intended interpretation.

I am not sure if you read my last reply to you, if not I would really like you to read it (on page 10 last post of me)
zznoor
Posts: 1017
Joined: Sun Dec 06, 2009 1:38 pm

Post by zznoor »

tret wrote:
zznoor wrote:
agakhani wrote: Brother Treat,

Good thinking above and we all should try that way but I have one question for you Tret, Do you think she will change? if she had ever realized the truth of Ismailism then she would not have left this true and correct path 'ISMAILISM'. period so I do not have much hope but who knows I have seen many Ismailis came back after they left Ismailism and realized that they make mistake and came back so, we all should keep our finger crossed hopping that happen to sister ZZNoor.
Truth is in Quran and authentic Sunna, not in Biddati material or firkas.
True! But the true path is through which the correct interpretation of Islam is done. Qur'an is full mysteries and hidden secrets and a Guide is a MUST for the correct and intended interpretation.

I am not sure if you read my last reply to you, if not I would really like you to read it (on page 10 last post of me)
I read your comments. I must honor admin's request to stick to thread subject.
tret
Posts: 1196
Joined: Thu Sep 09, 2010 2:09 pm

Post by tret »

zznoor wrote: I read your comments.
And...?
tret
Posts: 1196
Joined: Thu Sep 09, 2010 2:09 pm

Post by tret »

ShamsB wrote:
tret wrote:I don't think paining everyone with the same brush is wise of us.

And I don't think we should beat zznoor up just because she doesn't agree with us. After all 'shak' [doubt] is a stage of reaching to haqiqat and realization. If we can make her [zznoor] realize the truth, then I guess we have done something good. So, I think we should let her participate in the discussion and who knows, maybe one day she opens up her mind and start listening. I am very certain that she is intelligent and smart.

nuseri - I don't know why you need to compare our belief system with christology to make a point. Let christians praise christ and the concept of trinity. Don't get me wrong, I do respect Jesus. [He is after all our own Hz Issa AS].
Tret,

I am okay with zznoor stating that she wasn't happy with our faith and left it - or that she doesn't believe that our way or rather my way is the right way - but that doesn't give her the right nor the stance to judge me - last time i checked - she wasn't Allah.

Judge not lest you be judged (Jesus I think).

I am okay with her believing whatever she believes - what i object to is her putting garbage and copy pasting wahabist material in the middle of discussions.

For me - an individual's relationship to the almighty is between Ali/Allah and the individual - for me - there is no need or requirement for any intellectual proof or argument or debate. I believe what I believe and I find satisfaction and happiness with it - and I am happy for others to believe whatever they want to; however as you said - don't paint us with a paintbrush - just because zznoor is seeking validation for her decisions - she's hellbent on attacking us.

and every time she's come up with her crackpot theories and garbage - we've debunked her so called truths with proofs from sunni sources...she began by calling herself sunni - then moved to Shia Ithna Asheri and now she's moved back to twelver - she changes her faith based upon what argument she can copy and paste...

there is no intellectual search there - because she cannot articulate her position nor is she even reading what people are writing - she's copying/pasting ...
from here to the wahabist site - or the twelver site and whatever responses they give her - she copies and pastes here...

I am surprised that Admin hasn't taken action.

Shams
Shams brother, I absolutely understand what you are saying. I know she becomes annoying at times. I also agree with you that she has no right to judge me/you or us. But, again it's her opinion and the good news is, it doesn't impact us at all. So, she can say all she wants. But, I am an optimist and give her the benefit of the doubt and hoping that one day she might see what we have to say with an open mind. I may be naive in thinking this way.
shiraz.virani
Posts: 1256
Joined: Thu May 28, 2009 2:52 pm

Post by shiraz.virani »

Nuseri...This is the 3rd time I'm asking this question to you...I hope to get a response from a marifati like you atleast this time
Nuseri wrote :

Quote:
One of the visible strings during Prophet's time was Salman Faras( Jibrael firasta/ Archangel Gabreil.)


Salman Farsi was H.Jibraeel[as] ???....Any proof to back this up ???
Any proof to back your claim up ???
a_27826
Posts: 321
Joined: Sun Jan 03, 2010 1:43 pm
Location: Da es salaam
Contact:

Post by a_27826 »

zznoor wrote:
Please could you post other Ayats stating physical features of Ali+lah+Allah with eyes,walking,sitting on throne,speaking,etc etc.
All human words used for Allah are used in their basic sense and meaning, and not with reference to their physical connotation. For instance, when, the word "sight" is used with respect to Allah, it does not mean that Allah has an eye like men and animals with which He sees. Similarly when we say that Allah 'hears' or 'grips' or 'grasps', it does not mean that He hears through ears, or grips or grasps with the hand like us. These words are used in a metaphorical sense and only a man of very poor intelligence would have the misconception that hearing or seeing or grasping is not possible except in the limited and specific sense in which we experience it.
to nuseri:

I agree with zznoor.

I believe its quite true that the words describing actions of God are in metaphorical sense.

Quran was revealed to people so that they can understand. The words which God used are in a metaphorical sense so that the people can understand.

Jesus had similar problem in revealing the message from God.

Jesus is supposed to have said “I and God are one”. Some people took it literally.

If Jesus really said this, then he was trying to tell people to obey and follow him is same as obeying and following God.

John 10:30-33 - Jesus answered them, “I and My Father are one.”

Then the Jews took up stones again to stone him.

Jesus answered them, “many good works I have shown you from my Father: For which of those works do you stone me?”

The Jews answered him, saying, “For a good work we do not stone you, but for blasphemy, and because you, being a man, make yourself God.”

When God says taking allegiance to Muhammad is same as talking allegiance to God, does not mean Muhammad and God are one.

On other hand you can say they are one because obeying and following Muhammad is same as obeying and following God.

The point is: you have to recognize the hujjat of God, take allegiance to obey and follow him.

Conclusion: Read literal translations of the Quran and try to understand its esoteric meanings.
agakhani
Posts: 2059
Joined: Wed May 07, 2008 8:49 am
Location: TEXAS. U.S.A.

Post by agakhani »

I saw a Hindi movie more then 30 years ago, name was "YAHUDI" in this movies there was a dialogue which I still remember!!

'AAP KA KHOON KHOON HAI, AOUR HAMARA * KHOON KYA PANI?"

* (ISMAILIO KA).


This dialogue exactly fit to you sister, when you do not have any answer left and lately, which I point out in my earlier post, that you are completely out of your all defense weapons and you are miserably failed in your mission to harm the Iman of other readers in this forum but instead of harming the Iman of readers you are trapped in your own trap!! ' doesn't you created laughinga situation for you by your self!?? Don't you think sister, it is time for you to pack up your self along with your Garbage thought and believes and take an exit silently?.

In my opinion you should have to take an exit rather then taking Admin's easy shelter for an excuse?

I am also surprise like ShmasB was too! he wrote yesterday, why brother Admin let you put garbage from you, (which are nothing else but just copy, paste and save!!!?? I agree on that brother Shams.

that you are completely out of your all defense weapons and you are miserably failed in your mission to harm the Iman of other readers in this forum but instead of harming the Iman of readers you are trapped in your own trap!!
agakhani
Posts: 2059
Joined: Wed May 07, 2008 8:49 am
Location: TEXAS. U.S.A.

Post by agakhani »

I am not sure if you read my last reply to you, if not I would really like you to read it (on page 10 last post of me)
Yes bro, I read your comments on page # 10 and your answer is reasonable, the reason of delay I was thinking to read that book one more time and put my answer. But you are right if we think that way as you mentioned in that post. Every one have thier own interpretation whether it is Quran or any book Congratulation for decent thinking and opinion.
agakhani
Posts: 2059
Joined: Wed May 07, 2008 8:49 am
Location: TEXAS. U.S.A.

Post by agakhani »

Salman Farsi as an angel? I do not believe that whoever posted that is mistake.
However he was way advance in Ibadat and sacrificed himself from the punishments by his master so much that Prophet Mohammed told once

Salman faras is from Ahle Bait I think whoever posted above that Salman was angel must be messed up betwee. Ahle bait and an angel.
Admin
Posts: 6281
Joined: Mon Jan 06, 2003 10:37 am
Contact:

Post by Admin »

There is a hadith reported by Aisha. It goes like this: The Prophet said that he just got some Ayat from Jibrail but I only saw hie talking with the barefoot Salman,

I guess this may be the source of that belief that Salman was Jibrail

But there is also in a text of Massignon on Hallaj, the following hierarchy: A - S - M

Ali - Salman - Muhammad.


Self explanatory
zznoor
Posts: 1017
Joined: Sun Dec 06, 2009 1:38 pm

Post by zznoor »

that you are completely out of your all defense weapons and you are miserably failed in your mission to harm the Iman of other readers in this forum but instead of harming the Iman of readers you are trapped in your own trap!!
Shams brother, I absolutely understand what you are saying. I know she becomes annoying at times. I also agree with you that she has no right to judge me/you or us. But, again it's her opinion and the good news is, it doesn't impact us at all. So, she can say all she wants. But, I am an optimist and give her the benefit of the doubt and hoping that one day she might see what we have to say with an open mind. I may be naive in thinking this way.
Brothers
Jab pyar kiya to darna kya
So long I am respectful of your religion and MHI, why you guys are clamor ing for my head?
Ignore my post if you do not like. Sometime there is sarcasm in post, you should see it. After all you guys are expert in esoteric and Batini meanings.
Let's stick to the thread. Open up another thread so you can take out your anger, especially against me.
Salaam brothers
nuseri
Posts: 1375
Joined: Thu Jul 12, 2012 8:54 am

Post by nuseri »

Ya Ali Madad.
Thanks Admin for the post on Salman Farsi.

A Non Haqiqati who does have conviction of MHI as ALI n God can never acknowledge this status.

If ALI is seen as God so is soul of Jibreel need to seen near God(around Ahle Bayt) on Earth.

There is Farman on Imam SMS to study n understand soul.

To understand the soul of Salman Farsi as being a part of Ahle Bayt.
Even our Hazar Imam referred Him as Late Diwan Eboo Pirbhhoy.

On Diwan Imam said 'He is Salam Farsi and serving the Imamat from last 1400 years to the leaders,who are still living and confirming this.

Non Haqiaqti will ask proof proof n bray and ask.

How is MHI our Spiritual Father ?

As they still disbelieve the greeting of his Farmans even being an Ismaili.

If God is seen and identified so has the angels and more so the arch angel around Ahle Bayt during Most of the Imams of time has to be seen.

It is a Baatin conviction out of Love ,Ibaadat n Khidmat ( these 3 is not replaced by book n reading)and not just academic reading n reading alone.

Diwan a title is Indian royalty is a part of the royalty but not from the royal family. A title awarded in same spirit ,if one has a common sense that even Salam Farsi was conferred as a Part of Ahle Bayt but was not a Ahle Bayt himself.

If one notice n observe closely the greatness of prophecy period of Prophet Mohammed
that no physical hardship n violent death came to Him unlike there were hardship , violence n indifferent Death happened in prophecy with Moses n Jesus Christ.
It was ONLY because and Because of ALI n Salman were his physical companions.
The soul of prophet being utmost important being the last one.
It was safeguarded by GOD n Archangel Gabriel.
Believe it or not?
You cannot change my conviction by a question? I will surely try to upgrade your conviction by available info at hand.

To acknowledge it become a Haqiqati n experience,feel ,see and be blessed with HIS Spiritual Intellect have 101% faith in his Farmans
Ibaadat,Love for Him n Khidmat.

OUR IS A SUFI (BAATIN) TARIQA.many finding will need conviction of Baatin n Not all from Zahiri available data

You will never ever need explanation of GOD and His creations from others.
tret
Posts: 1196
Joined: Thu Sep 09, 2010 2:09 pm

Post by tret »

zznoor wrote:
that you are completely out of your all defense weapons and you are miserably failed in your mission to harm the Iman of other readers in this forum but instead of harming the Iman of readers you are trapped in your own trap!!
Shams brother, I absolutely understand what you are saying. I know she becomes annoying at times. I also agree with you that she has no right to judge me/you or us. But, again it's her opinion and the good news is, it doesn't impact us at all. So, she can say all she wants. But, I am an optimist and give her the benefit of the doubt and hoping that one day she might see what we have to say with an open mind. I may be naive in thinking this way.
Brothers
Jab pyar kiya to darna kya
So long I am respectful of your religion and MHI, why you guys are clamor ing for my head?
Ignore my post if you do not like. Sometime there is sarcasm in post, you should see it. After all you guys are expert in esoteric and Batini meanings.
Let's stick to the thread. Open up another thread so you can take out your anger, especially against me.
Salaam brothers
We are not afraid of our love and conviction towards our Imam, and I don't understand why should anyone be?

Second, who issued fatwa against you by expressing your view? Please go ahead and express your opinion, and be open minded to listen to ours. I requested you to give your opinion and view of what I had posted in my last reply to you, but got no answer/feedback from you. It's okay if you don't have anything to say now, or you are digesting it. Totally fine by me.

Sarcasm is okay, so long as it's backed up by reasoning and logic. We gave you reasoning and logic to disprove your sarcasm you made about beloved Prophet.

The reason why some of the members gets frustrated and annoyed is because you are not listening with an open mind and probably will not; but I still want to think that you may, one day.
tret
Posts: 1196
Joined: Thu Sep 09, 2010 2:09 pm

Post by tret »

nuseri wrote: ... OUR IS A SUFI (BAATIN) TARIQA..
I believe our tariqa is different than sufi, and certainly better. It certainly has its similarities but not exactly the same.

sufi says to completely abandon this world and have no attachments at all; however, ours say, to balance between the two; for, this physical world is of utmost importance for self-realization.
agakhani
Posts: 2059
Joined: Wed May 07, 2008 8:49 am
Location: TEXAS. U.S.A.

Post by agakhani »

So long I am respectful of your religion and MHI, why you guys are clamor ing for my head?
ACHHA! SO CHUHE KHA KAR BILLI HAJ PE CHALI!!??

No, you are not and you were not ever respectful to Ismaili religion and towards our beloved MHI, don't forget that I read your many posts since you joined in this website and I have collected many harsh words, sentences and harsh comments on our religion and MHI, let me give you just one example here for other readers ZZNoor has told and considered Ismailis as a " KAFIROON" many times in past !! Don't you believe this? then ask brother 'SHMASB' he will agree with me brother Shams please correct me if I am wrong, please...

So please do not take another easy shelter of white lies, I can put your disrespectful sentences here as many as you want but why don't you ask this question to your self? and he will give you true answer rather then adding another lie here?
Open up another thread so you can take out your anger, especially against me.
Not the anger but you have some different thing in your minds the real reasons to ask for another thread is below:-

1, You are out of defense weapons.

2, So that you can through even more garbage, more lies and weird believes here to harm the iman.

3, So that you can satisfied your own self that you have taken right decision converting from Ismailism to Sunny, 'CHALO DIL KO BAHLANE KE LIYE YE KHAYAL ACHHA HAI? but the real thing is totally different, you are reprieving for your big mistake.

Be honest with you, sister this is right time for you, when brother Admin and few other readers in this forum are in your side and when they are in sleeping mode right now!!( because they do not know your real mission and reason to come in this forum even after so many insults) , take vantage as you can before they wake up!!!

Walekum Assalam.
Locked